10 July 2012

Letter to Rhode Island Commissioner Gist

Note from Autistic Hoya:
This is a guest post from Andrew Collins, who is the co-chapter leader of the Autistic Self Advocacy Network Rhode Island, a member of the Governing Board of the National Youth Leadership Network, and a member of the Arc's Expert Advisory Committee. Formerly, he was the Public Relations Intern for Looking Upwards, Inc. 

_____________________________

Dear Commissioner Deborah Gist,

My name is Andrew Collins, Portsmouth High School class of 2012. Receiving my diploma was quite exciting—certainly one of the best moments of my life! I am writing to you because I feel as though this is a moment of glory every child should bask in.

I know you’ve heard much about this topic already, but please take the time to finish this letter. I hope that my personal example will be more effective than the angry calls and petitions. When I heard about the new diploma system, my excitement was inhibited by sudden sense of relief and fear; relief for being fortunate enough to pass the NECAP in 2012, but fear for those who may be receiving a certificate. I, a special education student who had received 4s on the reading and writing portion of the NECAP and nearly a 1 on the math portion, could have, on the right year and a bad day of testing, been one of the people who would be receiving the certificate in the new diploma system.

You were quoted in saying: “A piece of paper is not going to make a difference for a child, for any child in our state." Personally, getting a certificate instead of a diploma would have ruined me. Despite all your qualifications, you are not qualified to speak on behalf of every child in the state. I’ll say the same thing now that I said back in one of your 2011 hearings: this diploma policy fails to take into account the obvious emotional impact getting a certificate instead of a diploma would have on a diligent student, dismisses the fact that colleges and employers will notice the difference between certificates and diplomas, and assumes the state’s behavioral and academic support programs work well enough to ensure any hard-working student can meet the NECAP standards.

I just came out of the public school system as a special education student. I know what it’s like in there. My academic support program (it was an IEP) never really managed to get a handle on my learning disability in math; in fact the only reason I hardly managed a partially proficient score on the math section is because, as someone who has been tested as an intellectually “highly gifted student,” I managed compensatory strategies. A neurologically disadvantaged student who is neither bright enough to manage compensatory strategies nor fortunate to have a perfect support program is, speaking candidly, thrown under the school bus by the weight you place on the NECAP. Also, a student such as this or myself would almost never be able to earn your commendation on our diplomas, given we can get them. The fact that your commendation is only given to high-testing students is just another goal placed out of reach for disabled students. Instead, commend your students on their integrity, diligence, and passion.

Any way you look at it, people such as myself may be getting certificates solely because of learning disabilities we are neurologically incapable of overcoming. Being handed a certificate instead of a diploma, besides the obvious disadvantages it would put an otherwise bright person at, will in fact make an incredible difference. It would be one final, lasting, and forever inescapable branding of academic insufficiency and neurological abnormality. We’ve had our challenges; give us what we’ve earned.

Sincerely,
Andrew Collins

3 comments:

  1. Congratulations Andrew, and I can understand your sentiment. While I did very well in subjects in school, my verbal abilities were poor, but at the time I was schooled, those abilities were not required per oral presentations. I was lucky, my writing skills were poor as well, as I had problems with comprehension. But what was tested was rote memory for mostly multiple choice tests which I excelled at. I was also fortunate to be blessed with good math skills, although my sister who is diagnosed with Aspergers syndrome has dyscalculia, and had a much more difficult time than I did, because math was indeed tested.

    As I was progressing through college on my way to receiving three college degrees, the FCAT test became a requirement to graduate high school, but I honestly don't know if I could have passed it if oral presentation or writing skills were tested. Never the less I graduated close to the top of class of 380, without that requirement when I was in high school.

    My weaknesses in oral presentation and writing were waived because they were never tested, however I could have never have written a paper with any detailed content until years later when a keyboard and a screen became available.

    The weakness in math is a learning disability that is hard to overcome, as I understand through my sisters experiences, but I agree that one should not be penalized not as receiving a diploma because of a learning disability in one area. Those accommodations in math have not been matched like those in writing have through the use of assisted technology.

    There are plenty of areas in life that do not require excellent math skills; I would have traded some of those math skills for better verbal and writing skills, as that is what was in demand in the real world in most areas of employment.

    There was no diagnosis for autism spectrum disorders like mine at that time, so I had no understanding of why I could do so well in most every subject except for speaking and writing. Interesting that a person could graduate at the top of their class with those deficiencies, but it was possible per the standards that were required when I went to school.

    Good luck to you in all your future endeavors.

    ReplyDelete
  2. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plessy_v._Ferguson

    That's all I've got to say about that.

    ReplyDelete
  3. The fact that your commendation is only given to high-testing students is just another goal placed out of reach for disabled students. Instead, commend your students on their integrity, diligence, and passion.

    Public Relations

    ReplyDelete

If you are having difficulty commenting, try using the Name/URL option instead to avoid logging into any third-party service.